Premiering 60 years ago on September 8, 1966, Star Trek has continued to entertain and inspire generations of sci-fi fans the world over. Its pop cultural reach extends across regions, the decades, and even into the campus and archives at CatholicU…

John T. Dugan, MFA ’48 – Star Trek Scriptwriter
by Peter Goodman, Cataloging and Metadata Librarian
John T. Dugan (Oct. 11, 1920 – Dec. 24, 1994) was an American screenwriter who wrote for various television programs, including Bonanza, Dr. Kildare, Adam-12, Mission Impossible, Columbo, and Little House on the Prairie.
Dugan was nominated for the Writers Guild of America Award for Television: Episodic Drama in 1968, for the Star Trek: The Original Series episode “Return to Tomorrow”.
Dugan attended CUA in the 1940s. He was in the Speech and Drama department and wrote a Master’s thesis in 1948 (entitled “The Blue Turquoise”). It is a two-act play about love, set in 13th-century Tashkent (now in Uzbekistan). He went on to work on Star Trek, amongst other shows, and wrote the script for the episode “Return to Tomorrow“. In the episode, telepathic aliens take control of Captain Kirk’s, Dr. Ann Mulhall’s (Diana Muldaur), and First Officer Spock’s bodies in order to construct android hosts.

Writer John T. Dugan wrote the original script of this episode after he had read an article about highly sophisticated robots. In his original draft, Sargon and Thalassa continue their existence as spirits without bodies, floating around the universe. However, Gene Roddenberry, who did an uncredited re-write on the script, changed the ending to the aliens fading out into oblivion. This led to Dugan using his pen name John Kingsbridge in the episode’s credits. (The Star Trek Compendium)
Dugan (a devout Catholic) stated: “That line totally went against my philosophy and cosmology[;] I didn’t want to be associated with it. The oblivion idea is Roddenberry’s philosophy, not mine. (…) That might be a small thing, but I have a reputation and a philosophy and everybody who knows me knows what I stand for; I certainly don’t stand for oblivion in the afterlife. (…) When you write a script, you don’t expect to have your “world view” changed by a producer. The rest of Roddenberry’s changes were all trivial (…); the big thing was the change in the episode’s philosophy.” (These Are the Voyages: TOS Season Two, page 529)
Laurence Luckinbill, MFA ’58 – Spock’s Half-Brother
William J. Shepherd, University Archivist

What in the name of the United Federation of Planets does Catholic University have to do with the sixtieth anniversary of the television debut of the iconic Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS) on September 8, 1966? More than you might imagine as the university in that time was in the midst of a golden age of nearly a half century as its celebrated Drama Department under the legendary Fr. Gilbert V. F. Hartke produced scores of actors and actresses for stage and screen, including several who graced the corridors of the intrepid starship USS Enterprise during its ongoing mission in space. One such actor was Laurence Luckinbill, who shook the TOS based universe as Commander Spock’s revolutionary elder half-brother Sybok in the 1989 movie Star Trek V: The Final Frontier. The character was so controversial as a reforming zealot that the no longer active Star Trek creator, Gene Roddenberry, considered him non canonical. Sybok is basically a 23rd century version of Lenin whose transformative communistic vision for the galaxy collapses in ruins. Fans as well as Roddenberry question how the logical and lovable Spock could have such a miscreant sibling! Sybok’s vacuous catch phrase “I couldn’t help but notice your pain” because infamous in the 1990s, especially variations used by politicians, as the ultimate con demeanor to gain trust and power.

Amusingly, Sybok was originally written for Sean Connery, who was not available due to a previous commitment for Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. One chuckles at imagining the former James Bond in his Scottish brogue saying he keeps the brains of his mind numbed followers “shaken, not stirred.” So, what about the actor who actually brought this character to life? Luckinbill is an American actor, playwright, and director of film, television, and theatre. He is otherwise known for his one man shows based upon historical personages including Theodore Roosevelt, Lyndon Johnson, Ernest Hemingway, and Clarence Darrow. A native of Arkansas, he is a practicing Catholic with a BA from the University of Arkansas in 1956 and Master of Fine Arts in Drama from Catholic U in 1958. His Catholic U dissertation is entitled The Alien – A Drama in Two Acts. His television filmography is immense, with appearances on such popular shows as Columbo, Law and Order, and Murder She Wrote. Another connection to Star Trek is that he is married to Lucie Arnaz, daughter of Lucille Ball whose production company, Desilu, famously enabled the show’s two pilot episodes to be filmed (and the rest is history). Luckinbill retains his connection to CatholicU with several photographs preserved in the Archives of him attending various alumni events over the years.
The Star Trek Cinematic Universe – Reviews by the Bishops
Shane MacDonald, Curator of Digital and Museum Collections
If you journey from one quadrant of the stacks to another, you will encounter collections that expand the archival record of the Star Trek universe. The records of United States Conference of Catholic Bishops Office of Film and Broadcasting (OFB) contain correspondence, press kit packets, and media clippings around film reviews spanning the 1940s up until the 2010s. Founded as the National Legion of Decency in 1933, this ecumenical association monitored Hollywood films for moral and theological concerns. This system was influential in establishing and enforcing production controls, such as the Hays Code, in the entertainment industry. By the 1960s, the organization had become exclusively Catholic and was renamed the National Catholic Office for Motion Pictures and eventually the Office of Film and Broadcasting (OFB). By 2010, it was subsumed by Catholic News Service and finally Our Sunday Visitor in 2023.
While the height of its editorial power was largely past by the time Star Trek premiered in 1966, the series was a source of interest for the OFB film reviewers over the subsequent decades. Spanning its first feature film in 1979 up until the 2009 Kelvinverse film, and even looking at the television premiere of Star Trek: The New Generation, the film reviewers demonstrate the same wide range of reactions that Trek fans are long familiar with – boredom, confusion, comparisons to Star Wars, but also interest in the philosophical and melodramatic elements of the series. But the reviewers consider the films within the broader context of their genre and give them their fair due in the end.
While the main focus of the film reviewers, the memorabilia contained with the OFB files are a treat to any Trek fan, collector, or researcher. To learn more about University history or the cinematic treasures in the archives, contact us at: lib-archives@cua.edu





































